Christmas Dinner on Cape Cod – Where to go on Christmas Eve & Christmas Day

Our Cape Cod Christmas Dinner feature is new today, December 21, 2020. This feature originated on a few years back and it was always a very popular feature. Last year it appeared on our Massachusetts site, Go2.Guide, and this year it finally has found its new home on the Star!

We will update this feature as we find new restaurants for holiday dinners. For those of you looking for last-minute options, you can check out our listings for take-out holiday dinners at the bottom of the story.

Our guide covers the entire Cape. Our listings highlight our featured dinner, then dinners for Christmas Day and finally restaurants that are open for Christmas Eve only. If you know of an outstanding place that we missed, please let us know. Just leave a comment below or drop us a line.

Featured Cape Cod Christmas Dinner

Villaggio Ristorante in Cotuit

Villaggio is serving dinner on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. The hours for Christmas Eve are 3:00 pm to 10:00 pm and for Christmas Day, the hours are 12:00 noon to 8:00 pm. Chef Jay Bartolomei is serving his regular menu. Some highlights from his menu include Eggplant Rollatini with ricotta, crumbled gorgonzola and creamy pesto, a 24-ounce Bone-in Rib Eye, a 10-ounce Filet Mignon, Parmigiana with eggplant, chicken or veal ($20-24) and a Veal Piccata with garlic, shallots, Italian herbs, capers and a white wine lemon butter sauce ($26).
Call 508-548-5000 for reservations.

Cape Cod Christmas Dinner – Christmas Eve

P. B. Boulangerie in Wellfleet

Update, PB is offering a Christmas takeout dinner also. Boulangerie is only offering takeout from the Bistro because of the pandemic. The restaurant offers a take-out Christmas Eve dinner for two people for $250. That dinner features items like a pate de Campagne, a foie gras terrine, a seafood plateau with seven fishes and more.

The Pheasant in Dennis

Update: The Red Pheasant is now The Pheasant. With new owners and a new menu, the restaurant has changed dramatically. We have written the new owners and will update this part of the story when we get new information. For Thanksgiving, the Pheasant is doing takeout dinners for two. The Pheasant is busy planning their offering for Christmas. All orders are taken by phone at 508-385-2133.

Oysters Too in East Falmouth

Oysters Too has closed. The contents of the restaurant were just auctioned off. We are seeking a replacement for this part of the story. The restaurant served dinner on Christmas Eve with a special menu with a la carte pricing. Highlights from the menu include a Sole Menemsha with carrots, snow peas, shitake mushrooms, topped with lobster meat and scallops (29.95), Prime Rib (32.95), and a Lazy Lobster (33.95). Call (508) 548-9191 for reservations.

Barnstable Tuscan Cuisine

Barnstable Tuscan Cuisine is open for Christmas Eve. The website does not provide any details on what the menu will be.

Cape Cod Christmas Dinner: Pick Up & Take Out

  • Hearth & Kettle in Yarmouth & Hyannis is featuring a Christmas Roast Turkey Dinner Takeout for $19.99 each. See more.
  • Nauset Farms in Orleans is featuring a wide selection of holiday items for your holiday dinner. See More.
  • Whole Foods in Hyannis is featuring turkey dinners, ham dinners and even some vegan loafs for Christmas. See More.
  • Dan’l Webster Inn in Sandwich is featuring a Christmas Roast Turkey Dinner Takeout for $25.95 each. See More.

Hero Image: Copyright: subbotina / 123RF Stock Photo

Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top